In case you missed it, Matthew Dutton-Gillet, formerly rector at
Trinity Menlo Park (California)
was caught
misappropriating church funds for personal use, at least
$125,000 taken over the past five years. I was very disappointed
to learn of this news, but beyond that, I was surprised to note
that the idea of jail time for Matthew had not occurred to me
until some weeks afterward.
That was a blind spot for me. Matthew committed a crime, maybe
more than one, and he admitted this. How did it escape me that this
is a criminal case? I’m far from the only one; there are Trinity
members who to this day say that the police should not have been informed.
I suppose that because we like and respect Matthew, we don’t
want to think he’s also a criminal.
Speaking of “cognitive dissonance”…
Last November, we learned that
MPPC’s senior pastor, John Ortberg Jr., was put on personal
leave because of an error in judgment regarding a certain volunteer.
(In case you missed it,
here’s a timeline.)
Some things about the whole story were puzzling (why did that volunteer
confide in Daniel Lavery, formerly Mallory Ortberg?), but because I like
and respect John, I don’t like to think of him as recklessly
endangering children. I didn’t want to think about it;
I wanted all to be well. MPPC’s communications folks were ready
to help me with that.
As you can see, I have blind spots galore. When it was revealed earlier
this month that
the volunteer was John’s younger son, John III, some scales fell
off even my eyes. One puzzling question was shockingly answered, and yes,
it now seems to me astoundingly reckless to allow John III to be alone
with children to whom he felt sexually attracted.
In the week or so since I started writing this, I have seen a wide
variety of responses from people I know personally at MPPC. Apparently
I am not alone in my disorientation. As Jeremiah famously wrote,
“the heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure;
who can know it?” It is difficult—for me anyway—to
discern the severity and gravity of mistakes made by people we respect
or admire. I now have a new understanding of how deeply and severely
I at least can deceive myself.
Thus I am so very glad that the Lord Jesus Christ promised that
the Spirit of Truth would guide us into all truth. How much I need
to pay attention to that Spirit in these days!